Why Are My Pizza Toppings Burning? Quick Fixes For Perfect Pizzas

Picture this: you’ve spent all day perfecting that homemade pizza dough, you’ve carefully chosen your toppings, and you’ve even put together a killer pizza sauce.

You pop your pizza into the oven, and BAM! The toppings start burning like there’s no tomorrow.

Sound familiar? We’ve all been there, and it’s a total bummer.

But don’t fret, pizza lovers, ’cause we’re here to help you figure out what’s goin’ on and how to fix it.

We’ll share the reasons behind your pizza toppings burnin’ up, and share some tips to save your future pies from a fiery fate. 

Why Pizza Toppings Burn

There’s more than one thing that can cause you pizza toppings to get charred in the oven.

pizza coming out of pizza oven

Temperature Factors

When cooking pizza, the oven temperature plays a key role in determining the fate of the toppings.

If the pizza stone isn’t hot enough, the base will take longer to cook, leaving the toppings exposed to heat for an extended period, resulting in burnt toppings.

On the flip side, too much heat from the oven can cause the base and toppings to burn quickly.

So, finding the right balance between temperature and cooking time is crucial to keep the pizza toppings from burning.

Cooking Time

The total time the pizza spends in the oven also impacts how well the toppings cook.

With a well-preheated pizza stone, the base cooks faster, reducing the overall time spent in the oven, saving the toppings from burning.

You gotta strike the right balance between time and temperature, regardless of whether you’re using a wood-fired oven or a home oven.

Here are some tips to help control the temperature and cooking time:

  • Preheat your oven and pizza stone for at least 20-30 minutes before baking the pizza.
  • Ensure the pizza dough isn’t thicker than 1/8 inch to prevent the crust from scorching before the toppings are cooked.
  • Monitor the pizza closely while it bakes to avoid overcooking the toppings or the crust.

By carefully managing the oven temperature and cooking time, you can reduce the risk of your pizza toppings burning and enjoy a perfectly cooked pizza. 

Choosing the Right Equipment

Picking the right pizza gear goes a long way in preventing the burning of the toppings.

Pizza Stone and Steel

Using a pizza stone or a pizza steel is a great way to prevent your pizza toppings from burning.

A hot stone or steel can help cook the base faster, reducing the time spent in the oven and preventing toppings from burning.

Make sure to preheat your stone or steel for at least 30 minutes before baking your pizza.

Pizza Peel

A pizza peel is an essential tool for transferring your pizza to and from the oven.

Be sure to dust your peel with cornmeal, which will help your pizza slide easily onto the hot stone or steel.

Using a peel can also help you place the pizza in the center of the heat, ensuring that it cooks evenly and reduces the chance of your toppings burning.

Baking Sheet

If you don’t have a pizza stone or steel, you can use a baking sheet to cook your pizza.

Here’s how:

  • Place the baking sheet in the lower part of your oven, close to the heating element.
  • Preheat the baking sheet for at least 15 minutes before transferring the pizza from the peel to the sheet.
  • Use a pizza peel or a similar flat tool to transfer the pizza onto the sheet.

When using a baking sheet, keep an eye on your pizza and adjust the cooking time as needed.

You might need less time to cook your pizza properly to prevent burning the toppings.

Optimizing Your Dough and Crust

Here’s some tips making sure your dough and crust doesn’t burn.

Dough Recipe Considerations

When making pizza dough, it’s essential to consider the ingredients in your dough recipe.

One thing to look at is the sugar content.

Higher sugar levels can lead to faster browning and burning of your crust, as sugar caramelizes at 320°F (160°C).

On the other hand, dough with low or no sugar content will require longer bake times.

Flour is another crucial element, and you might find that using too much flour on the underside of your pizza can lead to burning.

So, be mindful of how much flour you’re using when preparing your dough and rolling it out.

Thick-Crust Versus Thin-Crust Pizza

Choosing between thick-crust and thin-crust pizza can dramatically impact how your toppings cook.

Thick-crust pizza can trap moisture beneath the toppings, causing them to steam and cook unevenly.

If you opt for a thick crust, make sure your dough is no thicker than 1/8 inch.

Using a rolling pin can help you achieve the proper thickness, ensuring that the pizza cooks evenly and doesn’t burn.

Thin-crust pizza, on the other hand, allows for better heat distribution, ensuring that your toppings cook faster and more evenly.

However, it’s essential to keep an eye on your pizza as it bakes, as thin crusts can also burn quickly if not monitored.

Following these tips for dough recipe considerations and choosing the right crust thickness will help to ensure that your pizza toppings cook evenly and don’t burn.

Toppings: Quantity and Quality

The problem might actually be with the toppings.

Avoiding Excess Toppings

When making a pizza, it’s crucial to be mindful of the amount and types of toppings used.

Going overboard with toppings can result in unevenly cooked pizza, burnt ingredients, and a disappointing taste.

Too many toppings can slow down the cooking process, leading to overcooked crust and undercooked toppings.

So, for a perfectly balanced pizza, it’s best to keep the toppings at a reasonable amount.

Strategies for Cheese and Other Ingredients

When it comes to cheese, the same rule of moderation applies.

Using too much cheese can cause problems, as it contains fat and protein that can burn under high heat, possibly increasing the risk of cancer.

Here are some strategies for using cheese and other ingredients:

  • Choose quality cheese: High-quality cheese melts better and creates a consistent, delicious layer on your pizza.
  • Grate your cheese: Grating the cheese ensures even distribution and better melting.
  • Balance toppings: Avoid piling up a single topping, as this can lead to burning, uneven cooking, and reduced flavor.

Aside from cheese, also consider the quality of other ingredients used.

Fresh, high-quality veggies and meats can significantly enhance the overall taste of the pizza.

Keep in mind that some ingredients, like squash, may be too mild in flavor and potentially water down the taste of the pizza.

Adjusting Cooking Techniques to Prevent Burning

You may not be cooking the pizza correctly, which is leading to the burnt toppings.

Using Direct Heat

When cooking pizza, it’s important to balance the heat from both the baking surface and the ambient heat around the pizza.

Too much heat on the base can cause the pizza bottom to burn, while excessive heat outside can cause the toppings to burn before the base is cooked.

She can start by pre-baking one side of the pizza, then removing it from the grill, flipping it, and adding toppings to the baked side.

This will ensure that the cheese melts and the toppings start cooking evenly.

Then, place the pizza back on the grill with the lid on to finish cooking.

Reducing Excess Flour and Cornmeal

If there’s too much flour or cornmeal on the dough, they could burn and cause the pizza toppings to cook unevenly.

To prevent this issue, she should:

  • Use only as much flour as needed to prevent the dough from sticking.
  • Dust off excess flour from the dough before adding toppings.
  • Use a lighter dusting of cornmeal on the baking surface or pizza peel to prevent burning.

By following these steps, she can avoid burning the pizza toppings and ensure a well-cooked, evenly baked pizza.

Similar Posts